NAIC Vendor Framework Draft Drops State-Law Compliance Certification

NAIC By InsureAI Wire. Published November 17, 2026.

Source: NAIC official document, content.naic.org (opens in a new tab)

A new NAIC vendor oversight draft covers third-party data and models used to price and underwrite property and casualty insurance. At the NAIC’s Fall National Meeting in Dallas, slides for the Third-Party Data and Models (H) Working Group’s November 16 session say the November 4 revision of the July 8 draft “is now officially exposed,” meaning released for public comment. They are the presentation of the chair, Colorado’s Jason Lapham; no minutes of this session are posted. Vendor registration stays voluntary.

Throughout the draft, “insurers” become “licensees”: any insurer, advisory organization, rating organization or similar body that prices or underwrites property and casualty insurance under state license or authority and is subject to examination by the state insurance department. July’s version used the word without defining it. The draft says vendor oversight “does not reduce licensee accountability.” Model suitability, validation and vendor data quality stay with the licensee, and so does compliance with laws on pricing, underwriting, unfair trade practices and unfair discrimination.

In the meeting materials, a redline of the November 4 draft shows vendor governance programs “are expected to be” consistent with the NAIC’s AI Principles and Model Bulletin; July said “must.” The annual attestation keeps a senior leader’s certification that the governance program is “implemented and effective,” drops one certifying compliance with each state’s insurance law, and adds one for records that let an independent party reconstruct all material changes. Material means “reasonably expected to significantly impact” a model’s performance, capabilities, behavior or risks.

Vendors are still “required to provide all information requested.” The list of examples, moved from the registry to the filing section, says they “should” supply them “upon request.” If a vendor does not, the regulator may prohibit licensees from using its data or model in the state, now “subject to each state’s applicable administrative procedures including written notice and cure period requirements.” Notice and cure means a written warning and time to fix the problem first.

The redline rests confidentiality on an NAIC data sharing agreement with each vendor and memorandums of understanding with participating states, whose own confidentiality and open records laws govern vendor information. Only states that attest they can protect confidential material receive it. July’s statement that the NAIC is not subject to open records laws is struck. Vendor names will be public, and intended uses may be.

The NAIC’s Innovation, Cybersecurity, and Technology (H) Committee draft minutes of August 14 record Lapham reporting five general themes in the August comment letters, which we reported in September. Set against that list, the redline by our reading answers three: the compliance attestation, confidentiality and the definition of material change. A fourth, whether registration is voluntary when use can be banned, stays open; notice and cure now precede a ban. We see no matching change on the fifth, duplication of existing state filing processes. The slides list “Revised after comment letters” under stakeholder input and say the November draft “adds clearer confidentiality mechanics, state notice-and-cure steps, and record-keeping expectations.” The draft itself gives no reasons.

The working group’s draft August minutes, posted with the November 16 materials, record Lapham hoping that, work permitting, the framework would be finished in time for consideration at this Fall meeting. His November slides end on comment that will “shape the framework before we consider adoption in the spring next year.” We read that as spring 2027, later than hoped; the slides commit only to considering adoption then. The working group’s page, like the slides and materials, gave no comment deadline for this draft on November 16, so letter writers have no date yet.

Share

Keep tracking

Information aggregation and analysis, not legal advice. See our disclaimer.